List of countries where language is a political issue
Categories: Sociolinguistics | Politics
This is a list of countries where language is a political issue. It is not a list of countries with more than one official language, or more than one language community.
Many countries in the world have more than one official language. This may simply reflect the existence of well defined groups speaking different languages, often including minority groups near borders, and in many such cases the use of multiple languages is unproblematic. However in some cases the issue of which language is to be used in what contexts is a major political issue, with the rights of particular language groups a constant source of political friction. Only these latter cases are listed here.
More than a question about language per se, such frictions generally illustrate the uneasy cohabitation of different cultural communities, sometimes with different ethnic origins. This is especially the case if one community dominates, or used to dominate, the other (better economical situation, control of government, etc.).
Assessments of gravity
The list attempts to give an idea of the gravity of the problem, but this is inevitably a subjective judgement and liable to change. The ratings are:
- Serious - language is a major organizing principle of the country's politics, and language disputes persistently threaten the unity of the country and/or involve violent protest or terrorist action
- Moderate - language disputes regularly arise, but are currently contained
- Minor - language issues are the concern of a small minority of the population (though those people may take them very seriously.)
List of countries
Note that only the languages in dispute are listed here; several of these countries have additional language communities.
- Algeria (Arabic and Berber): moderate to serious
- Belarus (Russian and Belarusian): serious
- Belgium (Dutch and French): moderate to serious
- Cameroon (English and French): moderate to serious
- Canada (English and French, particularly in Quebec; also, to varying degrees, English and Aboriginal languages): serious
- China (Chinese and various local languages): minor
- Cyprus (Greek and Turkish): serious
- England (English, Cornish): minor
- Finland (Finnish and Swedish): minor to moderate, see mandatory Swedish
- France (French), minor except Basque Country and Corsica: moderate
- Greece (varieties of Modern Greek): solved after 1975
- India (English and Hindi, Hindi and local language in some states): moderate
- Indonesia (Bahasa Indonesia and various native languages): serious
- Iraq (Arabic and Kurdish): serious
- Iran (Persian and Azerbaijani, Persian and Kurdish): serious
- Ireland (English and Irish): minor to moderate
- Kazakhstan (Kazakh and Russian): serious
- Latvia (Latvian and Russian): minor to moderate
- Macedonia (Macedonian and Albanian): serious
- Moldova (Russian, Moldovan, and Romanian): serious
- Netherlands (Dutch, Frisian): minor to moderate
- New Zealand (English, Maori and NZ Sign Language): minor to moderate
- Northern Ireland (English, Ulster Scots, Irish Gaelic): moderate. Irish Gaelic and Scots were officially recognised as regional or minority languages in 2001, when the UK ratified the European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages. Under the Good Friday Agreement, and subsequent legislation, both Irish Gaelic and Scots have cross-border, state-funded language boards.
- Norway (Bokmål and Nynorsk): minor to moderate
- Pakistan (Issue among the official language Urdu, the most common language Punjabi and regional languages such as Sindhi): moderate
- Philippines (Filipino based on Tagalog and English ): moderate. (English and Spanish: serious in past, now very minor, Cebuano native speakers resist Tagalog). See Languages of the Philippines
- Romania (Romanian and Hungarian): moderate
- Scotland (English, Scottish Gaelic, Scots): minor. Scottish Gaelic was granted official status in 2005, with 'equal respect' to English. Scots and Scottish Gaelic were officially recognised as regional or minority languages in 2001, when the UK ratified the European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages.
- Serbia and Montenegro (Serbian and Albanian, Serbian and Hungarian): serious
- Slovakia (Slovakian and Hungarian): moderate
- South Africa (English, Afrikaans and nine African languages): minor to moderate.
- Spain (Basque, Catalan, Galician and Spanish): serious. Aranese, Asturian, Basque, Catalan and Galician are co-official in certain regions. (Catalan and Valencian): serious).
- Switzerland (issues between French and German in some cantons): minor
- Taiwan (Mandarin, Taiwanese, and to some extent Hakka): moderate
- Timor-Leste- Commonly known as East Timor (Tetum and Portuguese in relation to Indonesian): moderate. Indonesian and English are considered working languages.
- Turkey: (Turkish is the official language; Kurdish and Laz are disputed languages): serious
- Ukraine (Russian and Ukrainian): moderate
- United States (English and Spanish; also English alongside Hawaiian (in Hawaii), French (in Louisiana), and various Native American languages (on Indian reservations)): minor to moderate (see also Spanish in the United States)
- Wales (English and Welsh in Wales: moderate to serious). Welsh is an official language in Wales.